And don’t bother cooling down, either
October 15, 2009 at 8:50 pm | In News, OW Training | 1 CommentTags: cool down, exercise science myths, Training
First we pointed out you have more to fear from Bambi than Bruce.* Now, another misconception put to rest, courtesy of the New York Times. To wit, a cool down is apparently worthless. Or at any rate, there’s no evidence it does you any good.
…the cool-down is enshrined in training lore. It’s in physiology textbooks, personal trainers often insist on it, fitness magazines tell you that you must do it — and some exercise equipment at gyms automatically includes it. You punch in the time you want to work out on the machine and when your time is up, the machine automatically reduces the workload and continues for five minutes so you can cool down.
The problem, says Hirofumi Tanaka, an exercise physiologist at the University of Texas, Austin, is that there is pretty much no science behind the cool-down advice.
(* The mechanical shark used in the film [Jaws] was nicknamed “Bruce” by its handlers, and the “full body” version tours around museums, while “Bruce II” resides at the Universal Theme Parks and “bites at” tourists on the tour ride. From IMDB.com)
An interview with Steven Munatones
October 13, 2009 at 8:46 am | In Interviews, OW Training | Leave a CommentToday we are thrilled to have a conversation with Steven Munatones, who may know more about OW swimming, swims, history, training, competitors, and techniques than any other human on the planet. He is the man behind 10KSwimmer, the encyclopaedic must-read blog for anyone interested in OW swimming. We don’t know how he manages to be everywhere at once in the world of OW swimming, but we are thankful he does.
Read on for our interview with Steven Munatones, with a few special tips for newer competitive OW swimmers at the bottom.
What would you like readers to know about you?
I see my role to help promote the sport, educate coaches and support athletes and parents in any way possible using every form of media available. I also see my role as a historian of the sport and helping document the rules and write about swimmers of all ages, abilities and backgrounds.
As a swimmer, when did you first become interested in open water swimming?
I did my first open water swim in Southern California at the age of 6.
How did it go?
It was in a bay in Southern California and, although I do not remember the result, the effect was extremely positive. I am still passionately involved in open water swimming 41 years later.
Worst open water swim you swam yourself? Worse you’ve witnessed or heard about?
The professional Around-the-Island Swim in Atlantic City, New Jersey in 1984. The water temperature dropped from the high 50’s to the low- to mid-50’s during the ocean part and I was pulled out with hypothermia. Of the over 25 experienced marathon swimmers who started, I think only 6 finishers. I was pretty disappointed in myself and committed myself to improving my ability to swim in cold water ever since.
What do you think is contributing to the growing interest in OW swimming? Where, geographically, do you see the most growth happening? What will help support its growth?
Several phenomena are occurring to booster the interest in open water swimming: The growing and sustained interest in triathlons, the addition of the 10K event to the Olympics, the ease of obtaining information on open water swimming via the Internet, and the increasing professionalism and excitement of local open water swims. Geographically, the engine of growth is Europe, by far. The European races are popular, professionally organized, televised on occasion and draw thousands in every kind of venue available. Brazil is also a hot bed for the sport with the Brazil Swimming Federation providing great leadership and vision. Domestically, the number of events in the US has increased threefold over the past several years with a large number of new events in the Midwest and in the South.
With the 10K now an Olympic sport, do you think we’ll see the 10K grow in popularity?
Not compared to the shorter races. The 10K is still pretty far for most swimmers and I believe it will remain in the realm of the elite or competitive swimmer. However, swims above 25K are showing tremendous growth among endurance athletes of all ages and abilities. So, the shorter races under 5K are, by far, the most popular (about 85% of all races in the US).
On that topic, do you think it’s likely we’ll see a growth in middle-distance events (5K-10K) or are there not enough swimmers interested in those distances?
We may see a slight increase, but nothing like the shorter events and the number of swimmers who will challenge themselves to the marathon swims above 10K.
Some open water races require entrants to submit proof of some kind of qualifying swim (for distance or time or both), but many don’t. With growing interest in OW swimming, do you think that USA Triathlon, US Masters swimming and USA Swimming should develop some kind of policy on qualifying standards for open water swimming?
The number of open water races that require proof of ability remains very small and I believe it will remain so. I think most athletes self-police themselves and do not attempt swims that they believe they may not be able to complete or competitively swim. USA Swimming has some standards for its national championship events, but I do not believe qualifying standards should be set by these organizations. The local race committee is in the best position to make these standards because each venue and each day provides different conditions for open water swimmers.
How do you manage to keep on top of all the information you share on 10K Swimmer? I’m constantly amazed at the breadth of your output!
I spend hours every day – 365 days a year – sifting through open water swimming information in all forms – and I have been doing this for decades. I have been studying, researching, observing and writing about open water swimming since 1982 so I have piles and piles of information that has yet to be posted, published, explained or shared. I also have reams of valuable and rare information on swimmers and events from other prolific writers or open water coaches or administrators – some whom have passed away – that I have yet to post, publish or analyze. In addition, many helpful individuals around the world send me information. Of all the information I receive, I estimate that I only post or publish less than 5%. I wish I could do this full-time in order to promote all the capable swimmers and wonderful events throughout the world.
How about that Eva Fabian? It seems as though a lot of the pro-level swimmers are older (mid-20s+), and Fabian is coming on gangbusters. What’s she doing that the rest of us should be doing?
Eva is a special young lady with a drive that is rarely seen domestically (in the open water world). Her coach and father, Jack Fabian, is also a special coach. They both seek knowledge about open water swimming and their minds are open to doing things differently than pure pool swimmers. Eva and her coach/father do special pool and open water workouts that Gerry Rodrigues and I have been advocating for years. Her father/coach takes the information that Gerry and I provide and modifies it as necessary. Eva has really stepped up to the plate and it is personally extraordinarily gratifying to see someone improve and move into the ranks of the world’s elite.
SOME QUESTIONS FOR THOSE OF US NEWER TO COMPETITIVE OW SWIMMING:
What’s the best approach for improving your sustainable speed over distances of, say, 5K and above? Lots of short, hard repeats w/ short breaks? Longer repeats with longer breaks? Long repeats, short breaks? Pyramids? A little bit of everything?
There are seven elements of success in the world of open water swimming. I can discuss these seven elements for hours, but your last phrase was smack on: A little bit of everything is required.
Turnover or efficiency? We know efficiency is important over long distance, but at the same time when we’re passed by the really fast people, their turnover is noticeably faster. What’s a good turnover speed for an ordinary mortal to aim for?
If we look at the turnover of the world’s best open water swimmers, they are usually doing at least 78 strokes per minute (39 cycles) and some of the them get above 84 strokes per minute. This is exactly the turnover they use in swim practice every single day. Depending on your age, strength, level of fitness and stroke technique, I would advocate at least a 75 stroke per minute pace must be maintained throughout any give race with a higher stroke count in the first 500 yards and last 500 yards of each race.
On the subject of turnover, we’ve also found it’s harder to maintain turnover speed in choppy/sloshy water. Any tips?
I know this answer sounds either corny or dismissive, but the best way to maintain turnover speed in choppy water is to practice in choppy water. Most people, however, avoid – or do not have the opportunity to – practice in choppy water. If you have access to the open water, I strongly advocate swimming in the late afternoon when the winds are strong at least a few times before a race, so you can become accustomed to such wavy and choppy conditions. Swimming in choppy water requires strength and a sense of balance that is best developed before the race.
Can’t get enough Steven M? Here’s a link to another interview.
Slideshow from the NYC Pro Swim
September 9, 2009 at 12:32 pm | In OW Training, Video | Leave a CommentTags: Eva Fabian, NYC Pro Swim, open water swim training
We don’t normally focus much here on the pro OW swimmers, but here’s a great slide show from last week’s FINA 10K Pro Swim in NYC that really captures the swimmers mixing it up in what looks like some pretty choppy water.
And speaking of the swim, kudos to 15-year-old Eva Fabian from New Hampshire, who finished a very close second in the women’s race. According to a recent feature on Fabian from SwimNetwork.com, Eva spends a lot of her training time in a 25 meter pool, so there’s some ingenuity in prepping her for open water events. The article quotes her coach describing some of her workouts:
a weekly set close to the distance she is competing in, for example 50 x 100 for a 5K or 100 x 100 for a 10K, we also do pace-line swimming with long repeats between 1,000 – 2,000 yards. We team Eva up with 2-4 other swimmers and they all take turns leading the pack for 50, 100 or 200 yards. They swim on each other’s toes, helping simulate the real-world race conditions at the world championships. The swimmers exchange leads so they get used to the surges and drafting that are so important in open water racing.”
“Eva also does some great POW [Pool Open Water] workouts where all the lane lines are removed and she races her teammates around the pool…. It teaches positioning and helps develop the ability to have fast turns in crowded conditions which are so important for open water success.”
What it takes to win: a Chris Greene update
September 7, 2009 at 8:53 am | In Chris Greene Lake Cable Swim, OW Training, Open Water Races | Leave a CommentThis year 19-year-old Abby Nunn won both the 1- and 2-mile events at the Chris Greene Lake cable swim. According to Lane 9 News, “Nunn, a 2008 graduate of Deep Run High School, trains under Coaches Geoff Brown and Brent St. Pierre and has been practicing seven times per week, averaging 8,000 yards per practice.”
That’s 56,000 yards a week, right? Back in May, I was feeling pretty happy with myself for doing 70,000 yards for the month.
Post workout recovery? Reach for your bowl & spoon.
May 15, 2009 at 8:40 am | In Caroline, OW Training, Video | Leave a CommentNotwithstanding that the FDA has recently chided General Mills for overstating the potential health benefits of your daily bowl of Cheerios, a new study says that a bowl of milk and whole grain cereal offers the same post-workout recovery benefits as fancy-pants sports drinks.
“Our goal was to compare whole grain cereal plus milk—which are ordinary foods—and sports drinks, after moderate exercise,” said [ exercise physiologist Lynn Kammer of the University of Texas at Austin]. “We wanted to understand their relative effects on glycogen repletion and muscle protein synthesis for the average individual. We found that glycogen repletion, or the replenishment of immediate muscle fuel, was just as good after whole grain cereal consumption and that some aspects of protein synthesis were actually better”.
“Cereal and non-fat milk are a less expensive option than sports drinks. The milk provides a source of easily digestible and high quality protein, which can promote protein synthesis and training adaptations, making this an attractive recovery option for those who refuel at home.”
Sing it, everyone!
May 12, 2009 at 2:51 pm | In Caroline, OW Training | 1 Comment
Tags: English Channel swim, Marcia Cleveland, open water swimming, open water training
Marcia Cleveland, English Channel swimmer, author of Dover Solo, and now a 45-year-old mother of 2, recently wrote for USMS about her current training schedule:
In the swimming part of my busy, busy life, this is an “off” year for me, meaning no major marathon swims planned such as the English Channel, Catalina Channel, the Chicago Shoreline Swim or others you may check out at my website, www.DoverSolo.com. I focus on shorter races, ranging in distance from 1 to 5 miles, and maintain my fitness by swimming three to four times a week (for a total of about 15,000 yards), a little running, lots of stretching, some dryland work and taking care of and goofing off with my family. When it’s an “on” year, my weekly swimming yardage is about 30,000 to 35,000 yards plus all of the above.
The article includes some tips and tricks for open water swimming, and Cleveland’s interesting admission (for a succesful Channel swimmer): “I have spent a great deal of time freaking out in open water…”
Swim with your eyes closed
April 18, 2009 at 4:27 pm | In Allison, OW Training | Leave a CommentThis morning, I did a short (hour-long) swim. In preparation for my first dip in the James (probably tomorrow), I did two things: I swam with my eyes closed, and I set the water in the shower as cold as possible. The last time I got in open water was probably last July
before my eardrum got smashed by a swimmer who stopped in the middle of the James at a Richmond Tri Club group swim, putting me out of the water for the rest of the OW season last September in the James. Needless to say, I’m itching to get in the open water!
I would highly recommend practicing with your eyes closed to anyone training for an OW race, unless the race is in the clear waters of the Caribbean, or elsewhere similar. In the past, I’ve not sighted enough, which has taken me off course at times. (Forgive me, I only started in 2006, and didn’t really get into it until 2007.) In open water, the only real consequence of this is having to swim more to get to the finish (which is obviously less efficient), but in the pool, you have a very narrow window before your arm hugs the lane line and you end up with red scrapes up your arm, or you hit the wall and smash a body part essential to swimming.
I closed my eyes, and only allowed myself to open them when I was breathing or sighting. I found that I sighted a lot more than when I swam in OW, and oddly, my stroke was a bit different — longer, more gliding than my typical pool swimming. I wasn’t doing this for time, so I can’t yet compare it to, say, a 100 free or 500 free at my normal pace. The exercise put me in the OW mindset, and I definitely think the longer stroke was more efficient for a distance OW race…and I felt calmer as I was swimming this way. I swam this way for just 300 yards, as I’m swimming Zones next weekend and needed to practice some other things, like the back-to-breast turn.
I should also note that I didn’t do flip turns. When I reached the wall, I thrusted my body in the other direction and began the next lap. Of course, you would not want to do this in a pool meet, but the advantage in training is that you’ll be taking a few more strokes per lap, essentially swimming more yardage, which hurts no one. You also aren’t giving your arms a “break” as you normally do during he flip turn, which more closely simulates swimming in open water.
As for the cold shower, I’m not sure exactly how cold the water was, but I hyperventilated a little. Cold showers are not fun. But if the water’s 65 or below on race day, I think cold-water acclimation is a necessary evil in the training process.
speed + distance = holy grail, part II
March 4, 2009 at 4:32 pm | In Caroline, OW Training | Leave a CommentToday’s distance swim was an experiment – long sets versus short sets.
I knocked off 7000 yards (OK, 6900–I miscounted one 2000 set), and for comparison’s sake I did the first 4000 in 2 sets of 2000 (or, if one cares to quibble, a 2000 and a 1900), then I did a single set of 1000 and then 4 sets of 500.
As is always the case on these longer swims, by the end my arms felt as though they’d been carved (and none too expertly) from hunks of wood, and around yard 4000 I started developing a deep, irrational, blood-sugar-deficit inspired hatred of the guy in the lane next to me for generating too much turbulence,
but…
it is also true that I was able to maintain my goal pace to the end by breaking the final 3000 into smaller sets, and this despite the fact that my shoulders and arms were still feeling the effects of major shovel work in the wake of this week’s freak March snowstorm (these days, any snowstorm in Richmond is freakish) and yesterday’s speed work.
In the continued spirit of scientific investigation, for my next distance swim, I’ll see if I can maintain a slightly faster pace over the distance if I break the whole thing up into 500s. Because the ultimate goal is to train at faster than goal race pace so that when you get to the race, your goal pace feels doable without those breaks in between. Right?
distance + speed = holy grail
March 4, 2009 at 10:20 am | In Caroline, Chesapeake Bay Swim, OW Training | Leave a CommentTags: open water swimming, swimming distance training
As noted here before, I’m a newcomer to the world of competitive swimming. I entered my first swim race (open water–I have yet to compete in a pool) shortly after my 45th birthday. On the one hand, this means that I don’t have the benefit of years of swim conditioning and competition behind me. On the other hand, I don’t have to reflect back wistfully on lost glory and those good old days when I could really put up the times. Instead, I can see a steady, if gradual, improvement in my swim pace since I began real training less than 2 years ago. I swim three days a week, by myself (a master’s team would be nice, but none of the local ones fit my schedule AND location together), so fortunately I’m capable of a fairly high level of self-inflicted suffering.
However, without the benefit of coaching, I’ve struggled with the question of how to get faster while training for distance, since both last year and this year I have had the Bay Swim’s 4.4 miles looming in my future. That’s a lot of 100 repeats.
So here’s a post from Alex Kostich at active.com that answers just that questions: How to Boost Your Swim Speed Over the Long Haul. For my own purposes, I put aside the laughable notion, as suggested within the article, that I could manage even a single 100 at a 1:09 pace, and simply translated the numbers towards my own goals (which include, as I believe I’ve mentioned previously, a sub-25-minute pool 1650).
“This workout is a basic yardage-covering workout, with an emphasis on repeating 100 yards at a consistently faster time than one normally swims in automatic mode. It covers distance without sacrificing quality, and the repetitive nature of the main set provides ample opportunity to swim fast and maintain race pace.”
Here’s another good article, from SwimCity.com, with a lot of good suggestions for training for speed over distance. OK, and it does all seem to come down to lots of shorter repeats.
“Rely more on repeats of 200 meters and less. It’s one of the best ways to train effectively for longer races. Because you can hold a much faster average pace for, say, 15 x 100-meter repeats than for a straight 1500 meters, you train your muscles and energy systems to do what it takes to move your body at faster speeds for that distance. You also get less fatigued than if you tried to swim the same pace in longer repeats, helping you maintain consistency in your training. Finally, it’s much easier to maintain good Stroke Length (and train efficiency into your muscle memory) on shorter repeats.”
OK, so that means that for today’s distance-day swim (goal: 6750 yards) I’d have to swim… 34 X 200. That’s a lotta repeats. Um, I’ll let you know how it turns out.
Grant Hackett technique
January 9, 2009 at 9:54 pm | In Caroline, OW Training, Video | Leave a CommentTags: Grant Hackett
Here’s a good video for studying freestyle technique. Yes, it’s in the pool, but Hackett ain’t no slouch in open water.
Blog at WordPress.com. | Theme: Pool by Borja Fernandez.
Entries and comments feeds.